CHARTS FOR SMART HR PROS: Turnover Is Back to Pre-Recession Levels Across America...
CAPITALIST QUOTES: "Enjoy Your Period of Low Engagement"...

Capitalist Definitions: "Manager Pass-Through"...

I wrote about the manager pass-through in 2011.  It's an important fact of life in every organization, so I'm writing about it again today.  Here's the trick:  Imagine you could film every manager in your organization trying to defend a strategy, action, change, etc. taken by the company to their team.  Would they own it or point to a higher power as the reason for the strategy, action or change, effectively separating themselves from responsibility for the decision/action?


Manager Pass-Through ((mn-jr ps thr)

1. What managers of people do when they don't want to own tough or difficult news with employees. 

2. Alive and well in every organization I've ever been a part of, and it's alive and well in your company. 

3. Rather than owning bad news or a difficult conversation with an employee, managers look for an easier out.  They/you explain deflective reasons why the action is necessary.  They/you often end up using terms like "them" and "we" to describe what's going on and why.

"Them" and "we" (and words that mean the same thing) are at the core of the manager pass-through.  Rather than explaining to your team member why a particular course of action is necessary for the business, you end up rationalizing - you say that you've been told to do something, and the conversation you're having is the next logical step.

It's not you who's asking for more or something uncomfortable from the employee, it's them.  Who is them?  Usually it's a tribe known as "management" or "leadership".  Could also be the customer.

Whoever "them" is, what you're doing when you use the manager pass-though is making it clear that it's not "you".

And it's lame.  Before I step off my high horse, allow me to confess - I'm guilty as well.  But the first step in recovery is acknowledging you have a problem.

The next time you're delivering bad news or asking for something you know is going to make a direct report uncomfortable, listen closely.  You may not say "them" or "us", but you're probably in the neighborhood. As a manager of people, sometimes you get paid to be in a lonely spot.  Own tough news or requests as your own, even if you didn't start the fire.

Good luck with the next conversation.  I hope the first day of the rest of your life as a manager goes really well.



Great post, Kris. I hear ya and I'm all for accountability and ownership, but this can be a slippery slope. Not sure that I necessarily want to "own" some of the poor decisions that "they" and "we" make, to be completely honest with you. So, I would argue, that there may be three buckets here. There's the stuff that we (people managers) need to own, there's the stuff that we (people managers) blame on someone else (manager pass-through) and then there's the crap that we just try to distance ourselves from altogether. And that line between the last two is a very thin line.


Seth -

I like the way you're going. I'd suggest that option 3, when warranted, is all about helping the employee cope with what the situation is, right?

"OK - so I can tell you're troubled, but I also know the reality isn't going to change. How can you maximize yourself and deal with this reality"?


Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)