My Photo

« Just Ask and Keep a Straight Face - You'll be Glad You Did... | Main | The Top 25 HR/Recruiting Blogs List From FOT and the Capitalist... »

March 21, 2012

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8345275cf69e2016764101c8b970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference ROWE (Results Only Work Environment) and the Holy Grail of Discretionary Effort...:

Comments

HRAthletics

It's the whole concept of defining expectations and the resulting intrinsic/extrinsic rewards beforehand. It's like, "Hey Josh, by the end of the 1st quarter I need you to:

- Develop and gain buy-in on a new talent management process. Work with IT and HRIS to get the system implemented. Roll it out and train leadership. We go live on 4/16."

On top of my day to day recruiting, labor relations, employee relations, etc..., I know what's expected of me for the next couple of months. If I complete the talent management process in 6 weeks, I can potentially check e-mails and take calls from home and be in the office on an as needed basis. Working from home for 2 weeks is a major motivating factor.

Candy Gray

Another one of those discussions where I vehemently agree with both sides! When the Netflix preso made the rounds, every CEO in the Bay Area (including my own) said "why aren't we doing that?" Of course my CEO followed that sentence by yelling out the door to his EA "where's so&so, why can't I ever find him when I need him, get him in here!" It all sounds good - until we find out "you can't handle the truth!"

TexasTwittHR

Conceptually, I like the idea of ROWE. In practice, I think there are too many unique characteristics about most of our organizations that make it nearly impossible to effectively implement it. Real or perceived, I think most organizations have too many "hurdles" to overcome to bring it to life.

Now earning the right to a ROWE? That is an interesting concept, but to your point Kris, you'd have to have a solid grip on employee performance and the stomach to deal with the whining that is sure to happen when employees have not earned the right to ROWE.

Another interesting thought is rotational ROWE. Consider the 9/80 work schedule. Employee works nine days and gets one day off. What if you rotated a ROWE? A quarter on, quarter off, quarter on, quarter off...across the entire employee population. I can poke holes in this arrangement as well...just a thought.

HRAthletics

I agree it's difficult for companies to grasp the value. Similar to Candy's point, I worked for a company that lost 9/80s because the EVP called for someone and they were on their Friday off. Like I said it's about defining expectations and rewards beforehand. Most companies can't do this because they don't know what they want from employees. But if they need something and you were unavailable to deliver, now it's a performance problem.

This concept forces proactiveness and intense planning. You can't expect this to work if you expect your employees to be admin assistants that know what you think and pick up your pen when you drop it.

Unfortunately I think most leaders still view their employees as property who are available when they have needs, as opposed to beings who want to deliver results, have purpose and be tied to the overall goals of the organization. They want someone to tend to them vs. deliver results.

Shelly Drymon

If you think some of your staff are just average employees and ROWE exposes them, why would you even want to keep them. Does the mandatory clock-watching, I'm at my desk, make them above average? No, regardless of the way of work of the office, they are still happy with average or doing the minimum.

It requires a change in mindset of everyone including management. They have to learn a different way of work and stop expecting staff to be at their beck and call. I have had that experience because my supervisor could not get her act together.

I agree with HRAthletics, that employeers see employees as property. I have quit my full time office job and I have gone ROWE and I can't imagine ever going back!

Richard

Just because someone's a poor performer in a traditional environment doesn't mean they'll be a poor performer in a ROWE. In fact, it may be the opposite!

ROWE is about treating everyone like adults. You set the expectations (as high as reasonable) and they're expected to follow through. If they can't, do they really deserve to work there, traditional workplace or not?

Everyone deserves to be treated like adult. Loosen your grip and they might surprise you.

NN

ROWE is an inevitable reality for Gen X & Yers. Millenials saw their parents and grand parents forego family for a nice car and a house they can't afford. The new generation does not want to rot away on the vine (or in the cubicle).

Companies must find a new way to motivate talent. Money is not enough. Especially when so many realize they don't need nearly as much material wealth. The financial crisis has shifted America's value system. Keep your shiny car, overpriced sneakers, cheap housing. I'd rather spend time with my family, reading by the lake or cooking for my family.

Time is the new money in the 21st century

Wim Van Nieuwenhoven

The idea of 'giving' ROWE to your stars immediately reminded me of the 'Free electrons' chapter in the Peopleware book (Demarco & Lister). If you haven't read it yet, find yourself a copy. I think alot of 'modern' ideas about management are already mentioned in there.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Subscribe!!!

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner